We have lived in New Albany for over a decade and are thrilled to share with you our favorite restaurants and places to find a drink and enjoy what the New Albany/Louisville region has to offer!
New Albany Restaurants
The Exchange Pub & Kitchen – This is one of our “go to” places in New Albany. Our favorite spot is on the bar side (where you can still get the full menu). The restaurant side can handle large parties and also has it’s own bar. If the weather is nice, don’t miss the outside patio! Google map.
Brooklyn and the Butcher – If you like a good steak, this is the place for you. For Tiffany and Brian, this is popular spot for a special occasion or a birthday dinner. Arrive early for your reservation and visit the speak-easy-type bar downstairs for a drink. Google map.
Pints and Union – Right in the heart of downtown New Albany, their motto perfectly explains the atmosphere, “Progressively old world public house, creative small plates, classic cocktails and comfort beers.” The upstairs section has room for large groups. Google map.
MESA Collaborative Kitchen – Located in the heart of downtown New Albany, this unique dining option features well known local and regional chefs cooking meals live in front of you, all while engaging with you and teaching you their tricks! There are only about 20 seats each night, so reservations are required in advance. We had dinner here with friends one night for a meal with Peruvian Chef, Vanessa Felix, and it was fantastic. Each event is themed, so check out the schedule of events here. There’s also a great video on Youtube here that explains their mission and unique dining experience. Google map.
Hull and Highwater – This is a casual dining option with fresh seafood. Our favorites are the oysters and catfish po’ boys. Grab a drink and head upstairs to the viewing deck for great views of the Ohio River and the double-decker Sherman Minton bridge. Google map.
Dragon Kings Daughter – This Asian-fusion cuisine combines things like tacos and sushi. If you’re not into that, the traditional sushi options are amazing. There are two locations, one in downtown New Albany and another on Bardstown Road in Louisville. Our favorites are the Crunchy Munchy roll and the Robert Deniroll. Google map.
Israel’s Delicias De Mexico Gourmet – This is our favorite spot for Mexican food. It’s truly authentic and fresh, not that cheap slop you’ll get at some other Mexican restaurants. Israel’s is ranked the #1 Mexican restaurant in New Albany by Trip Advisor and Yelp and is only six blocks from the Bough House! Google map.
Toast on Market – This is one of our favorites for breakfast, brunch, or lunch. If you’re there for lunch, try the Spicy Chipotle Grilled Cheese (served with a bowl of tomato soup for dipping). Google map.
Habana Blues Tapas Restaurant – This is a great restaurant for Cuban and Spanish style tapas. The empanadas and albondigas are amazing. It’s a large place and can accommodate big groups if you need to. Google map.
Proof on Main – It’s pricey, but this is one of the best restaurants in Louisville. For us, it’s a special occasion type of place, but if you’re looking for a meal you won’t forget, this is your place. Located at 21C Museum and Hotel, the art galleries flow into the restaurant with artwork everywhere in the dining area. Eating here is truly a unique experience. While you’re there, don’t miss seeing the galleries in the museum – they are free and open 24/7. Google map.
Garage Bar – An old auto garage converted into a restaurant by the owners of 21C, this is an eclectic eatery in the heart of the NULU district. They serve great wood-fired pizzas, locally grown ham plates, and oysters, along with a good selection of craft beer and cocktails. If the weather is nice, play a game of ping-pong on the outdoor glass-topped ping-pong tables (which are mounted to crushed automobiles). Google map.
Monnik Beer Company – The beer here is delicious – some of our favorite in the region. If you like IPA’s, you won’t be let down if you try theirs. And the food is great too. Give the Jackfruit Chorizo Papas Tacos or their Bier Burger a try. Monnik is in the Germantown neighborhood of Louisville. Google map.
LEO’s List of Best Breweries – Here is a quick run-down, compiled by LEO Weekly, of some of the best breweries in the Louisville/New Albany area. Find the list HERE. Some of our favorites are on the list, like Monnik, New Albanian, Great Flood, and Gravely. All of them on the list are great, though!
Hammerheads – Hands down, this is one our favorite restaurants in town. If you love BBQ, you have to try this spot. It’s a locals type of place, so you won’t see many tourists here. The pork belly PBLT is to die for, the ribs are amazing, and the duck sliders are delicious. It’s a casual hole-in-the-wall kind of place so no need to wear your finest. Google map.
Holy Grale – This restaurant and bar is housed in a small church built in 1905. As they say on their website, “Good beer, food and company is the only thing we pray for in this house of worship.” Here you’ll find 27 taps of some of the most eclectic beer selections in the area, along with a rotating selection of dishes with seasonal, local ingredients made southern style. It’s a small place, so it can be tough to bring large parties there, but there’s more room upstairs in the choir loft. Google map.
Joy Luck – In the heart of the Bardstown Road area of Louisville, Joy Luck serves fusion “far-east faire”. You’ll find dishes like Taiwanese Boneless Duck, Honey Walnut Shrimp, and Sweet & Spicy Ginger Fish on the menu. Our favorite is to start with the Pork Buns appetizer and then order the Beijing Roast Duck. There are also lots of boutique shops, bookstores, bars and restaurants in this area, so if the weather is nice, spend some time walking on Bardstown Road in either direction from Joy Luck. Google map.
Gravely Brewing Co. – At Gravely, you’ll find lots of great locally brewed beer and delicious food from Mayan Street Food. Snack on their Mexican Street Corn and Fried Plantains while you wait for the Black Bean or Chorizo Salbutes. This is good spot if you have a large group of people, too. Google map.
Mayan Cafe – The Mayan Cafe is known for traditional Mayan dishes, while also using local sustainable ingredients. It has been a staple in the Louisville restaurant scene for a long time, so make sure and get a reservation! Google map